FoodGood Friday flavours: Herring with caramelized onions recipe

Good Friday flavours: Herring with caramelized onions recipe

Good Friday is one of the most symbolic days in the liturgical year. For many people, it involves not only religious reflection but also specific customs, including culinary ones. In the Catholic tradition, it is a day of fasting and restraint, during which we forego meat dishes in favour of simple fasting meals.

Pickled herring
Pickled herring
Images source: © Adobe Stock | Copyright: Iakov Filimonov
Katarzyna Gileta

One of the most classic choices is herring – a fish that has been a staple on tables for centuries during such occasions. Its flavour, though intense, can also be subtle and deep – especially when paired with well-prepared onions.

Today, I propose a recipe for herring with caramelized onions – a simple yet flavourful dish that is perfect for Good Friday. The combination of the fish's saltiness and the onion's sweetness creates a result that's hard to forget. And although the recipe doesn't require many ingredients, its simplicity is its greatest strength.

Herring with caramelized onions – recipe

Ingredients (for about 4 servings):

  • 400 g herring fillets (preferably matjes),
  • 3 large onions,
  • 1 tablespoon butter + 1 tablespoon oil,
  • 2 teaspoons brown sugar (or white),
  • 1 tablespoon apple or wine vinegar,
  • Freshly ground pepper,
  • Optional: 1–2 bay leaves and a few allspice berries (for marinating).

Instructions:

  1. If using salted fillets (e.g., matjes), first rinse them thoroughly, then soak in cold water or milk for a few hours (preferably 2–3). This will reduce excess salt, making them more delicate in flavour.
  2. Peel the onions and cut them into thin slices. Heat the butter with oil in a pan. Add the onion and fry over very low heat for about 15–20 minutes, stirring often. When they soften and start to lightly brown, add sugar and continue sautéing until they caramelize – they should become golden and slightly sticky. Finally, add vinegar, mix, and remove from heat. Season with pepper.
  3. Drain and dry the herring, then cut into smaller pieces (e.g., each fillet into three parts). Layer them in a dish, alternating with the caramelized onions. If desired, you can add a bay leaf and allspice between the layers.
  4. They taste best after a few hours or the next day when the flavours meld. Store in the refrigerator for up to 3 days.

A tradition that tastes different

Although herring is one of those dishes often associated with Christmas Eve, it appears on Good Friday tables in many homes as well. Its preparation doesn't require much effort or many fancy ingredients – yet it can surprise with its taste.

Caramelized onions soften and complement the natural intensity of the herring, creating a duo that is both classic and slightly more refined. It's worth trying this recipe on Good Friday – as an expression of respect for tradition and culinary aesthetics, finding strength in simplicity.

Related content