AI avatar sparks controversy in landmark New York court case
A man who used an AI-generated avatar in court, hoping for a persuasive argument, faced sharp criticism from the judges. The court was initially unaware that the figure speaking in the presented recording was created by artificial intelligence.
In March 2025, an unusual event took place in the New York State Supreme Court. A man decided to utilise an avatar generated by artificial intelligence to present his arguments before a panel of judges. His hopes for an effective presentation were quickly dashed - reports fortune.com.
An unusual case in New York. An avatar testified in court
During a live broadcast, which occurred on 26th March 2025, on the YouTube channel of the Appellate Division First Department of the New York State Supreme Court, the AI avatar appeared on the screen in the courtroom.
The man who decided to take this step hoped that the technology would assist him in better presenting the case. Unfortunately, his idea met with sharp criticism from the judges, who were not satisfied with such an approach to the trial.
The use of artificial intelligence in the judiciary raises numerous controversies. Although this technology holds the potential to streamline various processes, its application in such a formal environment as a court requires caution. Experts emphasise that while AI can support lawyers in data analysis, decisions and arguments should be presented by humans.
The future of AI in law
This case demonstrates that although technology is developing at a brisk pace, its integration with traditional legal systems requires careful consideration and appropriate regulations. Introducing AI into courts can offer benefits, but it must be preceded by thorough analyses and tests.
